cranky home
Reviews since 1993:   A-E     F-N      O-Z    Posters       Who We Are and Why We Do What We Do         Search the Site

Your Donations support the Site

Top Selling DVD     Books

50 Shades of Grey
Exodus Gods and Kings
Grand Budapest Hotel
Imitation Game, The
Into the Woods

Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit
Theory of Everything
Ride Along
We're the Millers
The Great Gatsby
The Avengers
Amazing Spider-Man
Girl w/ Dragon Tattoo
Dark Knight Trilogy
World War Z
Happy Feet 2
Iton Man 3 combo
Batman Begins
Dark Knight
Fifth Element
The Hangover
Hunger Games
James Bond 11 disc coll.
Lord of the Rings trilogy
Mission Impossible GP
Sherlock Holmes AGOS
Singing in the Rain
Snow White Huntsman
Star Trek Into Darkness combo
Star Wars Saga
21 Jump Street
Ultimate Matrix coll
X-Men First Class
X-Men Trilogy
X-Men Wolverine

 BLU-Ray for Family DVDs 
Alice in Wonderland (2010)
A Bug's Life
Chronicles of Narnia set
Harry Potter 1-8 collection
Iron Man 2 combo
Kung Fu Panda
Lord of the Rings Trilogy Pinocchio
Pirates of Caribbean trilogy
Pixar short films
Shrek the Whole Story
Sleeping Beauty
The Smurfs
Snow White & 7 Dwarfs
Star Trek motion pictures set
Star Trek TNG Season One
Star Wars Saga (1-6)
Toy Story combo
Toy Story 2 combo
Toy Story 3 combo
Wall-E SE


Search engine by FreeFind
Click to add search to YOUR web site!
click to search site

Alice in Wonderland
Beauty and the Beast
Kung Fu Panda
The Lion King
Mary Poppins 45th LE
Princess Mononoke
Shrek the Whole Story
Simpsons Movie
Spider-Man Trilogy
Spirited Away
Star Trek movies set
Star Trek TOS (TV)
ST:TNG complete tv set
Star Wars Trilogy (1-3)
Star Wars Trilogy (4-6)
Toy Story DVD combo
Toy Story 2 DVD combo
Toy Story 3 DVD combo
Wallace and Gromit
Wall-E SE

Buy Movie collectibles
TV/Movie Collectibles

movie review query engine

NY film critics online

Privacy Policy

Click for full sized poster

Buy the Poster

Lady in the Water

Starring Paul Giamatti and Bryce Dallas Howard
Screenplay and Directed by M. Night Shyamalan

IN SHORT: . [Rated PG-13 for some frightening sequences. 120 minutes]

That we expect M. Night Shyamalan to drop a big surprise and plot twist in all of his movies has become, as we expressed in previous reviews, a monkey on his back. That monkey has been banished in his latest endeavor, Lady in the Water, which keeps the supernatural environment we expect and buries it in more laughs than we've gotten from all of Shyamalan's previous movies, combined. That's a good thing. Actually, that's about the only good thing about Lady in the Water. It's an incredibly funny movie. As funny as its story is impenetrable and our feeling about that was confirmed over and over again by the folks sitting in the row behind Cranky, muttering amongst themselves "I have no idea what is going on" or "Do you know what's going on?"

A big problem is that writer/producer/director M. Night Shyamalan does it all himself. That means no one catches what we'll call minor glitches, and the whole story rests on one of these "glitches" so the background comes first. Stuttering nebbish Cleveland Heep (Paul Giamatti) is the Superintendent at an apartment complex called The Cove. Its filled with many interesting, shall we say "unusual" characters like Reggie (Freddy Rodriguez), who is a body builder working only one side of his body and Vick, a writer who hasn't written a thing in six months but who is told that his current project will bring great change (of a good sort) to the Universe.

Why he believes that story, told by a character named Story (Bryce Dallas Howard), is just something you have to believe. Story saved Cleveland from certain drowning in the complex pool and, though she doesn't live in the complex, she cannot leave because of this big wolf like thing that has appeared, seemingly intent on hunting her down. You should also know that there are a pair of stories tossed at you as the film begins that seem nothing more than set up. They're not but haphazard delivery will do that.

Which brings us to the word "NARF". When the word "narf" becomes so important to the story that its earlier use is referenced in later dialog, we sat there wondering "Who said 'narf' and when?" Part of that is easy to answer and the rest of it, like many clever characters introduced in the first act entertains without adding anything to the story. Yeah, we know it's supposed to be background color. It takes up way more than background space, which may be fine for an ordinary drama but not for what we expect from Night. As we wrote, monkey. "Narf" leads to an old Chinese woman who tells the kind of bedtime fable one tells to children, to our favorite nebbish. To this point, our audience was still laughing pretty well and the story didn't seem any more important than any other less-important thing we'd been introduced to. Wrong.

Lady in the Water is based on the kind of bedtime fable one M. Night told to his children. As one who has also made up stories for kidlets, the form of this one is familiar: a story is started. It continues night after night and is made up from whole cloth. As a bunch of pieces it makes no sense but as a whole, let's just say as long as the end is happy, the story is said to work. Be glad there are plenty of laughs in the first act because act two is downright confusing -- even more confusing than the first act -- and act three adds the horror we expect, before devolving into something just as confusing as all that had come before.

Oh, wait, we forgot to mention the new kid in the complex, film critic Harry Farber (Bob Balaban) who exists to allow Shyamalan to poke fun at any critic that has done him wrong. As written, all made up as he goes along.

There's a coherent story here somewhere. It is definitely in the mind of M. Night Shyamalan but he gets only one view from your Cranky. He's made a film that is perfect for rental, because you'll need the multiple views to figure out what is going on.

On average, a first run movie ticket will run you Ten Bucks. Were Cranky able to set his own price to Lady in the Water, he would have paid . . .


Rent. Watch a zillion times. You'll need to.

amazon com link Click to buy films by M. Night Shyamalan
Click to buy films starring Paul Giamatti
Click to buy films starring Bryce Dallas Howard
Click Here!
Lord of the Rings merchandise -
The Cranky Critic® is a Registered Trademark of, and his website is  Copyright © 1995-2008 by, Chuck Schwartz. Articles by Paul Fischer Copyright © 1999 - 2006 Paul Fischer. All images, unless otherwise noted, are property of,©, ®, T their respective studios and are used by permission. All Rights Reserved. Not to be used or copied for any commercial purpose. Academy AwardT(s) and Oscar®(s) are registered trademarks and service marks of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

Your Donations feed us

buy Cranky gear!
Buy Cranky stuff
Click Here to Pay Learn More

Click here to buy posters!
Buy movie posters!


Star Wars Trilogy (Widescreen)
(Full Screen)
Lord of the Rings Trilogy DVD

Marx Bros collection
hitchcock dvd
Alfred Hitchcock Collection

Looney Toons
Volume 1
Volume 2
Volume 3
Rocky & Bullwinkle
Season 1
Season 2
Season 3
Star Trek TOS
Star Trek TNG
Star Trek Films

Criterion Collections

Buy Movie collectibles
TV/Movie Collectibles

Click here for your favorite eBay items

online movie critics

Privacy Policy

Labelled with ICRA
We're Kidlet Safe

Search engine
by FreeFind
Click to add search to YOUR web site!
click to search site

   Now in Release:

The Band's Visit
Definitely Maybe
Hottie and the Nottie
In Bruges
Iron Man
Be Kind Rewind
Mad Money
U2 3D

28 Weeks Later
Black Book
Bourne Ultimatum
Brooklyn Rules
Death at a Funeral
The Ex
Georgia Rule
Harry Potter - Phoenix
The Hoax
Hot Rod
I Know Who Killed Me
La Vie en Rose
License to Wed
Live Free or Die Hard
Mr. Brooks
No Reservatons
Ocean's Thirteen
Perfect Stranger
Pirates of Caribbean
Rescue Dawn
Rush Hour 3
Simpsons Movie
Slow Burn
Snow Cake
Spider-Man 3

    DVDs on Sale:
Alice in Wonderland
Batman Begins
Beauty and the Beast
Blade Runner
Bridge to Terabithia
Charlie + Chocolate Factory
Fantastic Four
Forrest Gump
Gone With the Wind
Harry Potter yrs 1-3 set
Harry Potter Azkaban
The Incredibles
Indiana Jones trilogy
The Lion King
Lord of Rings 12 discs
Mary Poppins 40th LE
Ultimate Matrix set
Miss Potter
Monty Python - Grail
Napoleon Dynamite
Pirates of the Caribbean
Pirates of the Caribbean 2
Shrek 2
Sin City
Sleeping Beauty
South Park Movie
Spider-Man 2
Star Wars Ep. 1
Star Wars Ep. 2
Star Wars 3 Full Screen
Star Wars 3 l'box
Star Wars Trilogy (4-6)
The Island
War of the Worlds
X-Men 2

The Cranky Critic website is Copyright © 1995  -  2017  by Chuck Schwartz. Articles by Paul Fischer are Copyright © 1999 - 2006 Paul Fischer. All images, unless otherwise noted, are property of,©, ®, their respective studios and are used by permission. All Rights Reserved. Not to be used or copied for any commercial purpose. Academy Award(s) and Oscar®(s) are registered trademarks and service marks of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.